We probably have around 40. There would be more, but I regularly cull the more unpopular ones. I like buying them new toys, but I live in a two room apartment. It's small. We don't have room to keep every single toy that I buy for them, especially if they never play with it. Little C has around 20 that she plays with daily. She has two absolute favorites that we all have to sleep with. Sometimes, we sleep with them all, though. If I go to bed early because I'm sick or something, it's going to be a squeaky night because she will bring every single toy to me in turn, hoping I'll throw it even though I'm asleep. Sir N has only a few he will play with. His favorite is his kangaroo and the koala that was supposed to be Little C's is probably his second favorite. He never makes me sleep with them, though.