Joined
·
7,840 Posts
OK-so I am a pretty big American Idol and Nashville Star fan...
I have watched them every season...probably because it is one of my dreams that won't ever come true...except I wanted to sing on the Grand Ole Opry Stage...so I REALLY like Nashville Star better!
So, just wondering what you have thought about the American Idol season so far? The contestants, the song choices, etc. What about the ones that have been kicked off? Who do you think will get kicked off tonight?
This is my opinion so far on American Idol...GIRLS: I REALLY thought the little Janay girl should have gone last week. I don't think she is gonna make it far...as far as the rest of the girls...some of them have more talent than others, but all of them are REALLY good. I think I am going to be disappointed sometime down the road because I really like the girls that are leading toward the country genre and most of America is not going to lead that direction!!!
Last night...the judges got onto Carrie Underwood (my fav so far) for getting AWAY from her country songs...and the song she sang WAS a country song!!!
And she was awesome! I didn't get it!
MEN: Lots of talent...some are better performers than singers...I wish they would lose the band and back-up singers so that we can actually hear THEM! The Nikko guy from St. Louis was AWESOME singing "Lets Get It On!"
I don't understand why they are just letting them pick their own songs this year...it is all so different. In the past they have had a different genre or era of music they had to sing each week, so that we could see their diversity. Why are they not doing that this year? Just my opinion, but I can't say those rocker guys are going to be all that diversified
. Anyway, I liked the different music and seeing how they approached it each time.
I don't know which two are going tonight...it makes me sad because I can't really choose! I like lots of them!
Nashville Star...
Last night was the first night...it was great! One girl was supposedly sick and ended up running off the stage...food poisoning+nerves they said...
Poor thing!
Anyway, it will be interesting too to see who makes it...
So, do ya'll think I am nuts?!
It's ok..it gives me something to talk about with my kids at school b/c lots of them watch it too...

I have watched them every season...probably because it is one of my dreams that won't ever come true...except I wanted to sing on the Grand Ole Opry Stage...so I REALLY like Nashville Star better!

So, just wondering what you have thought about the American Idol season so far? The contestants, the song choices, etc. What about the ones that have been kicked off? Who do you think will get kicked off tonight?
This is my opinion so far on American Idol...GIRLS: I REALLY thought the little Janay girl should have gone last week. I don't think she is gonna make it far...as far as the rest of the girls...some of them have more talent than others, but all of them are REALLY good. I think I am going to be disappointed sometime down the road because I really like the girls that are leading toward the country genre and most of America is not going to lead that direction!!!



I don't understand why they are just letting them pick their own songs this year...it is all so different. In the past they have had a different genre or era of music they had to sing each week, so that we could see their diversity. Why are they not doing that this year? Just my opinion, but I can't say those rocker guys are going to be all that diversified


I don't know which two are going tonight...it makes me sad because I can't really choose! I like lots of them!

Nashville Star...
Last night was the first night...it was great! One girl was supposedly sick and ended up running off the stage...food poisoning+nerves they said...

Anyway, it will be interesting too to see who makes it...
So, do ya'll think I am nuts?!

