Haven't tried either. Spookie just likes regular rawhide chewies, her grumpy 13 yo Poodle brother leaves them alone. If there is anything else in the house, he gets them, and share is NOT in his vocabulary!! LOL
Hmmm ... I'll have to look again at the site ... and if I can't get an exact idea on the size, I'll contact them.Bella really enjoyed it when I gave her one...But it was the small one and she put the whole thing in her mouth and started walking with it...Worried that she might choke on it I took it from her and put it in the Kong and she chewed one point of the star and wont touch it again...I wont let her chew it without the kong so if I were you Id maybe order the medium size one...I believe there is 3 sizes.