Kristi,I think you have to look to your babies for this answer.Do they have senistive tummys? I would say start out with a small amt. each day plus their kibble. If they seem to tolerate it well just keep decreasing the amt. of kibble you give them.One other thing though,do not let the homecooked food set out for longer than an hour if they dont eat it.Either put it in the frig& reheat it later or throw it away.I would also start them out on turkey first and if they do ok on it with no problems then I would go with the others.leanbeef,chic etc.Cottage cheese,yogurt are good also.